Myths and Misconceptions
Are Aftermarket Shocks the solution to poor suspension action?
Myths & Misconceptions
You have to establish what level of performance you want to gain by modifying the suspension. For the rear shock, a new spring and a revalve will take
a lot of the harsh feel out of the shock, and will improve plushness and help control squat. These mods will give you a superior shock when compared
to the standard unit. The aftermarket shock will have an advantage, mostly in the way the adjusters work, the piston design and the slippery surface
finishes.
My suspension appears to handle better two-up than solo?
People often say a bike that is underdamped and undersprung works better with more load. It actually doesn't but will move around less. The suspension
action will still be harsh and to get the best you would need to re-spring and at least revalve or consider PMA options. The harshness will be masked
by the extra load and give the impression of a better ride. Basicly you need to decide what application/ riding style is most important to you (e.g.
ride-day, sports, touring) and from there you can narrow down the equipment necessary to do the job.
Steering is too light and shakes - I need a steering damper?
Most headshake problems, especially with an application of sports/touring come from the rear shock. It unloads the front as the back squats too far, and
this causes headshake in most situations.
A steering damper's job on a roadbike is to control side-to-side oscillations of the front wheel (headshake). As an extreme example - consider a Race
Bike where the front wheel will very likely come off the track. If it hits a bump when it comes down it can cause headshake; the job of a steering damper
is to stop these oscillations. They may be of a particular amplitude to not self-cancel. The steering damper does this for you. When the suspension is
correctly set-up with springs and damping to suit the rider and the application, for most road and not-too-serious track conditions, the steering damper
is not needed.
Nitride treatment to forks makes a substantial difference?
No, while the surface is a lot more slippery, it doesn't produce massive real-world differences. It also means you can't repair stone damage - it just will
not polish up like chrome, it's too hard. The surface treatment demands closer tolerances, better alignment or the advantages will be mostly lost in a
sloppy front end. So if you want the best in low friction and you put a high end coating on, then the rest of the fork must be brought up to a similar
high end level of engineering.
Does the rear actually RISE under acceleration?
"Does the rear actually RISE under acceleration? If the swingarm were not connected to the bike via a rear shock, the force of the drivechain would obviously
pull the swingarm away from the tail unit and it would spin around the swingarm pivot towards the front wheel. If the bike is moving, will the momentum of
the rider force the rear to squat? or will the force of the drivechain still make the rear end rise?"
(Jack Anstice)
Graham Byrnes -
Yes, but it depends. It's not just the chain, but the fact that the tyre is pushing back against the road and so the road is pushing the bottom of the tyre
forward, equal and opposite reaction, Newton's 3rd law. Which is after all what causes the bike to accelerate.
Now if you look at the swingarm, it slopes down to the rear axle. So when the tyre is pushing the axle forward, it tries to move forward underneath the
swingarm pivot, which lifts the back of the bike. This is easy to check; squeeze the front brake and start feeding out the clutch as though to do a burn-out
and the back will rise. This is called "anti-squat" geometry. If you use the rear brake, it will pull down because the force is being applied to the brake
caliper rather than the ground.
However, there are 2 complicating factors:
Is it true that a "Non-rebuildable Shock" is not able to be re-built?
Over the years we have not yet found a shock that we can't rebuild. The biggest factor is usually the cost to rebuild such things.
Most modern shocks (let's say from late 80's) are able to be converted into a re-buildable and fully serviceable shock for a minimal cost
increase, usually a regas valve. Some require machining to have them opened and then we install clips and regas valve to complete the job.
The most expensive rebuild is when we have to return the shock to original condition i.e. chrome and overall appearance for a restoration.
More Preload makes the spring stiffer?
A spring's job is to be able to compress almost fully and then return to it's free length without any changes to length or rate. When you "preload"
a spring it simply means you compress the spring with a load or adjuster before any vehicle/bike load is put on the spring. So if you have a spring
that has a rate of 1Nm per mm and when you assemble the forks you compress the spring (preload) 10mm with the adjuster backed right off, then that
is "fitted preload". The usual preload adjuster has a further 15mm of preload range, this means the total force you have stored in the spring is 25Nm.
To make the fork move you have to exceed this load, and then the rate increases by 1Nm because that's the spring rate. What makes it feel more stiff
is that instead of starting at 10Nm it starts at 25Nm because the one force is higher than the other. This is what gives you the feeling of a stiffer
spring.
I can 'borrow' my mate's suspension settings and have them work for me?
Each rider has a different riding style and favourite way of turning a motorcycle into a corner. The adjusters on motorcycles are for you to
trim or set-up the way the motorcycle behaves to suit your riding style. So the best thing you can do is work them out for yourself, as you will
have your own unique way of doing things. (See
road/race set-up and tuning;
offroad set-up and tuning)
© ProMechA + Graham Byrnes